Where can I find a tire shop near me in Ithaca, NY?

If you’re looking for a tire shop in Ithaca, NY, this location provides tire sales, installation, balancing, rotation, and tire repair for passenger cars, SUVs, and light trucks. In addition to tires, the shop also offers brake service, oil changes, wheel alignments, flat tire repair, and other essential auto services - making it a convenient option for drivers in and around Ithaca.

Do I need an appointment at the Cole Muffler in Ithaca, NY, or do you take walk-ins?

Appointments are recommended, but walk-ins are welcome for many services. Common walk-in services often include flat tire repair, oil changes, and tire replacement when inventory and bay availability allow. helps secure the earliest available time, and calling the store is the best way to check on same-day availability.

What auto services does the Cole Muffler in Ithaca, NY offer?

This location offers a wide range of auto services, including tire installation and repair, brake inspections and repairs, oil changes, wheel alignments, battery replacement, suspension and steering service, TPMS service, and inspections. These services are provided to help keep your vehicles safe, reliable, and road-ready year-round. View all of our tire and auto services .

What tires fit my vehicle, and are they in stock at Ithaca, NY?

You can use the to search by vehicle, tire size, or license plate to view current pricing and availability at the Ithaca location. The store carries a wide selection of tire sizes and styles, including all-season, performance, and winter tires. If a specific tire isn’t in stock, it can often be ordered and delivered quickly (often the same day) for installation.

Do you offer same-day service at the Ithaca location?

Same-day service is often available for common services such as tire replacement, flat tire repair, oil changes, and brake inspections, depending on workload and parts availability. Morning usually offer the best chance for same-day appointments. For more urgent needs, calling the store directly is recommended.

Is this a full-service auto repair shop in Ithaca, NY?

Yes. In addition to tire services, our Ithaca auto repair shop provides brake service, oil changes, wheel alignments, battery replacement, suspension and steering repairs, air conditioning service, TPMS service, and other routine maintenance. If a specific repair requires specialized equipment, our team can help direct you to the nearest location that offers it.

Home All Stores LocationsCole Muffler Ithaca (Cole), NY

Cole Muffler in Ithaca, NY

Address: 227 Elmira Rd., Ithaca (Cole), NY 14850Directions

Finding Store Hours

607-247-1762

Call Us

4.8

1006 reviews

Tire Shop & Auto Repair in Ithaca, New York

Cole Muffler is now part of the Mavis Tire Family!

Tire Deals Near Me

SAVE $100
$100 INSTANT on select sets of 4 tires
Offer instantly applied
Free rotation included
Learn More
Valid from 2/1/26 - 2/28/26
SAVE $50
Save $50 INSTANT
Offer valid on sets of 4 Mavis Mountaineer A/T2 tires
Free rotation included
Learn More
Valid from 1/5/26 - 2/28/26
ALL-SEASON TIRES STARTING AT $73.99
30-Day Price Guarantee
40K+ Mileage Warranty
Great All Season Traction
Everyday low prices
SUV TIRES STARTING AT $99.99
40K+ Mileage Warranty
30-Day Price Guarantee
Great Wet Weather Traction
Everyday low prices

Auto Service Specials

Save $20 on Oil Changes
Valid For Most Vehicles
Proven to Maximize Engine Life with Valvoline Motor Oil
Includes Tire Rotation and Brake Inspection
Learn More
* Offer Expires 12/31/26
Save $35 on Wheel Alignment
State-of-the-art Equipment
Free Visual Alignment Check
90 Day Warranty Included
Valid on Most Cars
Learn More
* Offer Expires 12/31/26
Save up to $140 on Brake Service
Free Visual Brake Inspection
Includes Front or Rear Brake Pads (or Shoes)
Includes Labor
Valid on Most Cars
Learn More
* Offer Expires 12/31/26
Save $20 on Battery Service
Free Visual Battery Check
Warranty Included
Learn More
* Offer Expires 12/31/26

Store Details

Cole Muffler in Ithaca, NY. Get Directions

Payments Accepted

Cash

Visa

Mastercard

American Express

Discover

Goodyear Credit Card

Store Credit Card

CFNA Bridgestone Credit Card

Flex Shopper Credit Card

Hours

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

Top Auto Services

Tire Replacement
Need new tires in Ithaca, NY? Our local tire shop provides professional tire replacement and installation for cars, SUVs, and light trucks. We handle mounting, balancing, and proper fitment, for safe handling and even tire wear. Most tire sizes and models are available for same-day installation, and our technicians verify your fitment before every install.
Brake Repair
Looking for brake service in Ithaca, NY? We provide brake inspections, pad replacement, rotor service, and complete brake repair, to keep your vehicle stopping safely. If you're hearing squealing, feeling vibrations, or noticing reduced braking performance, our technicians can diagnose the issue and recommend the right fix - often with same-day availability.
Oil Change
Looking for a fast oil change in Ithaca? We offer conventional and synthetic oil changes using high quality motor oil and OEM-grade filters, to help protect your engine. Fluid checks and basic inspections are included at Cole Muffler, and many oil changes are completed the same day. Regular oil service helps improve engine performance, and it extends the life of your vehicle.
Flat Tire Repair
Dealing with a flat tire in Ithaca? Our shop provides professional flat tire repair, using industry-standard tire plugs and patches when the damage is able to be repaired. At Cole Muffler, we carefully inspect every tire for safety and let you know whether a repair or replacement is the best option. Walk-ins are welcome for many flat tire repairs.
Wheel Alignment
If your vehicle is pulling to one side or your tires are wearing unevenly, it might be time for a wheel alignment in Ithaca. Proper wheel alignment helps to improve handling, extends your tire life, and helps to restore the correct steering angles. Our technicians use modern alignment equipment to help keep your vehicle driving straight and stable.
State Car Inspection
We perform certified state vehicle inspections at our Ithaca, NY location. Our technicians check all required safety and emissions components, to make sure your vehicle meets state regulations. At Cole Muffler, inspections are handled efficiently and correctly, so we can help you stay compliant and avoid any unnecessary return visits.

Loading reviews...

TrustPilot Reviews

Browse Popular Tire Brands:

Loading results...

Mavis Credit Card

Get 15% Back (Up to $150) As a Visa Prepaid Card by Mail or Email

with a purchase of $799 or more made with your Mavis Tire credit card at a participating Mavis Tire location. Offer valid on purchases made 2/13/2026–3/14/2026. Rebate form must be submitted online or by mail postmarked by 4/13/2026.

See If You Prequalify Download Rebate

Already a Mavis Credit Cardholder? Manage & Pay My Card

* subject to credit approval. Minimum monthly payments required. See store for details.

The "MAVIS DIFFERENCE"

Rolling with you for over 70 years

Convenience

Choose from over 2,100 locations in 36 states

Price

We will beat any price

Selection

Largest selection of tires for any vehicle

Selection
Largest selection of tires for any vehicle
Convenience
Choose from over 2,100 locations in 36 states
Price
We will beat any price
Selection
Largest selection of tires for any vehicle
Convenience
Choose from over 2,100 locations in 36 states

Frequently Asked Questions

Popular Tires in Ithaca, NY

Frequently Asked Questions

Cole Muffler in Ithaca, NY

SAVE $100

SAVE $50

ALL-SEASON TIRES STARTING AT $73.99

SUV TIRES STARTING AT $99.99

Save $20 on Oil Changes

Save $35 on Wheel Alignment

Save up to $140 on Brake Service